A Conversation Across Time: Sitting Down with George Washington

by Kay Godfrey, Historian

There are moments in a historian’s life when the past feels especially close—when the voices we’ve studied for years seem almost within reach. Today, I invite you into one of those moments. Imagine, if you will, a quiet room, a simple wooden chair, and across from me sits the man so often called the Father of Our Country: General George Washington.

The Persevering General

Kay Godfrey: General Washington, thank you for granting this extraordinary conversation. Let me begin simply—when you reflect on your life, what do you believe was your greatest challenge?

George Washington: Sir, I should say that perseverance was my greatest trial. The war for independence was not won by a single victory, but by enduring hardship—cold winters, scarce supplies, and uncertainty. It required faith… not only in Providence, but in the cause of liberty itself.

As he spoke, there was no trace of arrogance—only a quiet steadiness. This was not the distant marble figure we often imagine, but a man who had felt the full weight of responsibility.

The Danger of Unrelinquished Power

Kay Godfrey: Many remember you for your leadership in war, but I’m equally interested in your decision to step away from power. Why was that so important to you?

George Washington: Power, when held too tightly, becomes a danger to liberty. After the war, and again after my presidency, it was my firm conviction that the republic must not depend on one man. If we were to succeed, we must demonstrate that leadership could be surrendered willingly.

There it was—the defining principle of a republic. Not just winning freedom, but protecting it from the very human temptation to hold onto control.

Unity: The Goal We Continually Pursue

Kay Godfrey: In today’s world, many look back at your time as one of unity. Did it feel that way to you then?

George Washington: I fear that is a generous interpretation. Even in our earliest days, we were divided by region, by opinion, by vision for the future. Unity was not a condition we enjoyed, but a goal we continually pursued.

It’s a sobering reminder. The early American experiment was never simple, never universally agreed upon. It was, and still is, a work in progress.

Liberty, Law & Virtue

Kay Godfrey: If you could offer counsel to future generations, what would you hope they remember?

George Washington: That liberty requires virtue. A nation cannot endure on laws alone. It depends upon the character of its people, their willingness to sacrifice, to act with integrity, and to place the common good above personal interest.

As our conversation drew to a close, I found myself struck not by grand speeches, but by quiet conviction. Washington was not seeking glory—he was seeking stability, responsibility, and endurance for a nation he knew was fragile. And perhaps that is the most powerful takeaway of all.

History is not built by perfect people – it is shaped by individuals who choose, again and again, to do what is right when it would be easier not to.

Final Thoughts

If we listen closely, voices like Washington’s still speak—not from monuments, but from the principles they lived. As a historian, I’ve spent years studying the past, but moments like this remind me why it matters.

Because the questions they faced… are not so different from our own.

Picture of About Kay Godfrey

About Kay Godfrey

He has studied and researched the life of the Prophet Joseph Smith for over 45 years. He has done extensive “on-site” research in New Hampshire, Vermont, New York, Pennsylvania, Ohio, Illinois and Missouri. He has spoken to the issue of the “Trials of the Prophet Joseph” at numerous symposiums in Nauvoo, Il. and Independence, Mo. He has edited books and videos for various authors on the historical accuracy of materials pertaining to Joseph Smith. Kay serves on numerous boards and foundations such as Ancient American Archaeology, Missouri Mormon Frontier Foundation, the Foundation for Indigenous Research and Mormonism and the Nauvoo, Illinois, and Topsfield, Massachusetts Historical Societies.

Additional Blog Posts